Overview of approaches to the study of the power – property model in Soviet Russia of the Stalinist period

Authors

  • Mikhail A. Beznin Vologda State University, 15 Lenina Street, Vologda 160000, Russia
  • Tatiana M. Dimoni Vologda State University, 15 Lenina Street, Vologda 160000, Russia

Keywords:

Stalinist period, economic development, power, property, research methodology
Supporting Agencies
The research was carried out at the expense of the grant of the Russian Science Foundation (No. 22-28-00325).

Abstract

The article is devoted to the review of approaches to the study of the power – property model in Soviet Russia in the late 1920s – early 1950s. The authors describe the main conclusions of domestic research of both the Soviet and post-Soviet periods, a wide front of scientific developments – in the field of history, economics, oriental studies, etc. In addition, the article presents an overview of the main conclusions of foreign, mainly European, researchers in the study of the model of power and property of the Stalinist period. The authors propose to consider the main institutions of the Russian power-proprietary system (ownership, marketability, planning, money), to study the subjects of proprietary rights, the system of divided property rights, the perception of property relations, etc. The proposed approaches will allow historical science to advance in the development of new research tasks for the study of the economic history of Russia of a unique period that entered science under the name of «Stalinist».

Author Biographies

  • Mikhail A. Beznin, Vologda State University, 15 Lenina Street, Vologda 160000, Russia

    doctor of science (history), full professor; head of the department of national history, Institute of Social and Humanitarian Sciences

  • Tatiana M. Dimoni, Vologda State University, 15 Lenina Street, Vologda 160000, Russia

    doctor of science (history), docent; professor at the department of national history, Institute of Social and Humanitarian Sciences

References

  1. Pivovarov YuS. [Russian property, Russian power, Russian thought]. Rossiya i sovremennyi mir. 2002;1:5–36. Russian.
  2. Bessonova OE. Razdatochnaya ekonomika Rossii: evolyutsiya cherez transformatsii [Distribution economy of Russia: evolution through transformation]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2006. 142 p. Russian.
  3. Nureyev RM. [Signs of the main production relationship and the discussion about the Asian method of production]. In: Sergeev AA, editor. Mekhanizm funktsionirovaniya proizvodstvennykh otnoshenii v usloviyakh razvitogo sotsializma [The mechanism of functioning of industrial relations in the conditions of developed socialism]. Moscow: [s. n.]; 1976. p. 212–218. Russian.
  4. Nureyev RM. [The Asian way of production and socialism]. Voprosy ekonomiki. 1990;3:47–58. Russian.
  5. Vasiliev LS. The phenomenon of power-property. On the problem of typology of pre-capitalist structures. In: Alaev LB, editor. Tipy obshchestvennykh otnoshenii na Vostoke v srednie veka [Types of social relations in the East in the Middle Ages]. Moscow: Nauka; 1982. p. 60–99. Russian.
  6. Vasil’ev LS. [East and West in history (the main parameters of problematics)]. In: Kradin NN, Korotaev AV, Bondarenko DM, Lynsha VA, editors. Al’ternativnye puti k tsivilizatsii [Alternative paths to civilisation]. Moscow: Logos; 2000. p. 96–114. Russian.
  7. Shamkhalov FI. Sobstvennost’ i vlast’ [Property and power]. Moscow: Ekonomika; 2007. 411 p. Russian.
  8. Nureev RM, Runov AB. [Russia: is deprivation inevitable? (the phenomenon of power-property in historical perspective)]. Voprosy ekonomiki. 2002;6:10–31. Russian.
  9. Berezhnoi IV, Vol’chik VV. Issledovanie ekonomicheskoi evolyutsii instituta vlasti-sobstvennosti [Study of the economic evolution of the institution of power-property]. Moscow: Zakon i pravo; 2008. 239 p. Russian.
  10. Pliskevich NM. Mutatsii «vlasti-sobstvennosti»: problemy i perspektivy [Mutations of «power-property»: problems and prospects]. Moscow: Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 2007. 57 p. Russian.
  11. Kolganov AI. To the critique of the «power-property» concept. Voprosy ekonomiki. 2017;7:79–95. Russian. DOI: 10.32609/0042-8736-2017-7-79-95.
  12. Venediktov AV. Gosudarstvennaya sotsialisticheskaya sobstvennost’ [State socialist property]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo AN SSSR; 1948. 840 p. Russian.
  13. Alekseev VV, Sakharov AN, Senyavskii AS, Korelin AP, Borodkin LI, Petrov YuA, et al., editors. Sobstvennost’ v XX stoletii. K 80-letiyu akademika V. A. Vinogradova [Property in Russia in the 20th century]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2001. 951 p. Russian.
  14. Katasonov VG. Ekonomika Stalina [Stalin’s economy]. Moscow: Institute of Russian Civilisation; 2014. 416 p. Russian.
  15. Khlevnyuk OV. Khozyain. Stalin i utverzhdenie stalinskoi diktatury [The owner. Stalin and the establishment of the Stalinist dictatorship]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2010. 478 p. (Istoriya stalinizma). Russian.
  16. Ostrovskii AV. Kto postavil Gorbacheva? [Who put Gorbachev?] Moscow: Algorithm; 2010. 544 p. (Sud istorii). Co-published by the «Eksmo». Russian.
  17. [Letters of V. G. Venzher and A. V. Sanina to I. V. Stalin]. In: Kuznetsova TE, Nikiforova LV, editors. Vladimir Grigor’evich Venzher: myslitel’, issledovatel’, uchitel’. [Vladimir Grigoryevich Venger: thinker, researcher, teacher]. Moscow: Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 2015. p. 138–176 (Vydayushchiesya ekonomisty Rossii). Russian.
  18. Stalin IV. Ekonomicheskie problemy sotsializma v SSSR [Economic problems of socialism in the USSR]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat; 1952. 96 p. Russian.
  19. Koznova IE. Stalinskaya epokha v pamyati krest’yanstva Rossii [The Stalin era in the memory of the peasantry of Russia]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2016. 464 p. Russian.
  20. Beznin MA. Krest’yanskii dvor v Rossiiskom Nechernozem’e. 1950–1965 gg. [The peasant yard of the Russian Non-Chernozem region. 1950–1965]. Moscow: Institut istorii SSSR AN SSSR; 1991. 255 p. Co-published by the Vologodskii gosudarstvennyi pedagogicheskii institut. Russian.
  21. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. [The completion of raskrestyanivaniya in Russia (the second half of the 20th century). Volume 1]. In: Sevost’yanov GN, editor. Rossiya v XX veke. Reformy i revolyutsii [Russia in the 20th century. Reforms and revolutions]. Moscow: Nauka; 2002. p. 632–643. Russian.
  22. Osokina EA. Za fasadom «stalinskogo izobiliya». Raspredelenie i rynok v snabzhenii naseleniya v gody industrializatsii. 1927–1941 [Behind the facade of «Stalin’s abundance». Distribution and market in the supply of the population during the years of industrialisation. 1927–1941]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2008. 271 p. Russian.
  23. Kondrat’eva T. Kormit’ i pravit’. O vlasti v Rossii XVI–XX vv. [To feed and rule. About power in Russia in the 16th–20th centuries]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2006. 208 p. Russian.
  24. Kondrashin VV. Golod 1932–1933 gg.: tragediya rossiiskoi derevni [The famine of 1932–1933: the tragedy of the Russian village]. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2008. 519 p. (Istoriya stalinizma). Russian.
  25. Zima VF. Golod v SSSR 1946–1947 godov: proiskhozhdenie i posledstviya [Famine in the USSR 1946–1947: origin and consequences]. Dmitrenko VP, editor. Moscow: Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 1996. 265 p. Russian.
  26. Menkouski V, Šmigeĺ M, Dubinka-Hushcha L. «The Hunger Games»: Ukrainian famine of 1932–1933 in history, historiography and historical policy. Banská Bystrica: Belianum; 2020. 270 р. Co-published by the Matej Bel University.
  27. fon Mises L. Socialism. An economic and sociological analysis. 6th edition. Kahane J, translator. [S. l.]: Liberty Classics; 1988. 596 p. Russian edition: fon Mises L. Sotsializm. Ekonomicheskii i sotsiologicheskii analiz. Pinsker B, translator. Moscow: Catallaxy; 1994. 416 p.
  28. Friedrich CJ, Brzezinski ZK. Totalitarian dictatorship and autocracy. New York: Praeger; 1961. 346 р.
  29. Bauer R, Inkeles A, Kluckhohn C. How the soviet system works. Cultural, psychological, and social themes. Cambridge: Harvard University Press; 1956. 288 р.
  30. Fainsod M. How Russia is ruled. Cambridge: Harvard University Press; 1953. 684 р. (Russian Research Center studies; volume 11).
  31. Schapiro L. The Communist Party of the Soviet Union. 1st edition. New York: Random House; 1960. 631 р.
  32. Daniels RV. The Stalin revolution. Foundation of soviet totalitarianism. 2nd edition. Lexington: Heath; 1972. 233 р.
  33. Meyer A. The soviet political system. An interpretation. New York: Random house; 1965. 494 р.
  34. Kassof A. The administered society: totalitarianism without terror. World Politics. 1964;16(4):558–575. DOI: 10.2307/2009446.
  35. Rigby TH. Traditional, market, and organization societies and the USSR. World Politics. 1964;16(4):539–557. DOI: 10.2307/2009445.
  36. Armstrong JA. Sources of administrative behavior: some Soviet and Western European comparisons. American Political Science Review. 1965;59(3):643–655. DOI: 10.2307/1953175.
  37. Barghoorn FC. Politics in the USSR. Boston: Little, Brown and Company; 1966. 418 р.
  38. Skilling HG, Griffiths F, editors. Interest groups in Soviet politics. 1st edition. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1973. 433 р. (Princeton Legacy Library).
  39. Bunce V, Echols JM. From soviet studies to comparative politics: the unfinished revolution. Soviet Studies. 1979;31(1):43–55. DOI: 10.1080/09668137908411223.
  40. Conquest R. Power and policy in the U.S.S.R. The study of soviet dynasties. 1st edition. New York: St. Martin’s Press; 1961.485 р.
  41. Hough JF. The Soviet prefects. The local party organs in industrial decision-making. 1st edition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press; 1969. 416 р.
  42. Menkovsky VI. Istoriya i istoriografiya: Sovetskii Soyuz 1930-kh godov v trudakh anglo-amerikanskikh istorikov i politologov [History and historiography: The Soviet Union of the 1930s in the works of Anglo-American historians and political scientists]. Minsk: Belarusian State University; 2007. 359 p. Russian.
  43. Berliner JS. The informal organisation of the Soviet firm. The Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1952;66(3):342–365. DOI: 10.2307/1885308.
  44. Berliner JS. Factory and manager in the USSR. Cambridge: Harvard University Press; 1957. 386 р. (Russian Research Center studies; volume 27).
  45. Gregory PR. The Political economy of Stalinism. Evidence from the Soviet Secret archives. New York: Cambridge University press; 2004. 308 p. Russian edition: Gregory P. Politicheskaya ekonomiya stalinizma. Markevich A, Kuznetsov I, translators. Moscow: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya; 2006. 400 p. (Sovetskaya istoriya v zarubezhnoi istoriografii).
  46. Kornai Ja. A hiány. Budapest: Közgazdasа́gi es Jogi Könyvkiadó; 1982. 610 a. Russian edition: Kornai Ja. Defitsit. Berzina S, Bulakh S, Zaikin V, Markov D, Mikhal’skaya A, Polyakov A, et al., translators. Moscow: Nauka; 1990. 608 p.
  47. Kornai Ja. The socialist system. The Political Economy of Communism. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1992. 672 p. DOI: 10.1093/0198287763.001.0001. Russian edition: Kornai Ja. Sotsialisticheskaya sistema. Politicheskaya ekonomiya kommunizma. Evstigneev RN, editor. Bolotin BM, Kazantsev SV, translators. Moscow: Zhurnal Voprosy ekonomiki; 2000. 672 p. (Universitetskaya biblioteka).
  48. Djilas M. The new class. New York: Frederick A. Praeger; 1957. 214 p. Russian edition: Djilas M. Novyi klass. New York: Frederick A. Praeger; 1957. 246 p.
  49. Voslensky MS. Nomenklatura. Gospodstvuyushchii klass Sovetskogo Soyuza [Nomenclature. The ruling class of the Soviet Union]. Pisarev MYu, editor. Moscow: Sovetskaya Rossiya; 1991. 624 p. co-published by the «Oktyabr’».
  50. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. [The initial accumulation of capital in Soviet Russia: an invitation to a scientific discussion]. Voprosy istorii. 2020;7:22–42. Russian. DOI: 10.31166/VoprosyIstorii202007Statyi02.
  51. Konstitutsiya SSSR [Constitution of the USSR]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat; 1947. 26 p. Russian.
  52. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. Collective capitalist property in the institutional structure of Russia in the 1930s–1980s. Ekonomicheskie i sotsial’nye peremeny: fakty, tendentsii, prognoz. 2020;13(4):186–201. Russian. DOI: 10.15838/esc.2020.4.70.11.
  53. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM, Gulin KA. Ekonomicheskii stroi Rossii 1950–1980-kh godov [The economic system of Russia ofthe 1950s–1980s]. Vologda: Vologda State University; 2021. 252 p. Russian.
  54. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. Agrarnyi stroi Rossii 1930–1980-kh godov [The agrarian system of Russia of the 1930–1980s]. Moscow: Lenand; 2014. 608 p. Russian.
  55. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. The Soviet Proto-bourgeoisie: genesis of the upper class of Russian society. Modern history of Russia. 2019;9(2):437–453. Russian. DOI: 10.21638/11701/spbu24.2019.209.
  56. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. «Over-production» management in the Soviet economy (1930–1980s). Voprosy istorii. 2020;10-2:42–60. Russian. DOI: 10.31166/VoprosyIstorii202010Statyi25.
  57. Beznin MA, Dimoni TM. [Social classes in the Russian collective farm-state farm village of the 1930–1980s]. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. 2011;11:90–102. Russian.

Downloads

Published

2022-08-08

Issue

No. 3 (2022): Journal of the Belarusian State University. History

Section

World History

License

The authors who are published in this journal agree to the following:

  1. The authors retain copyright on the work and provide the journal with the right of first publication of the work on condition of license Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial. 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0).
  2. The authors retain the right to enter into certain contractual agreements relating to the non-exclusive distribution of the published version of the work (e.g. post it on the institutional repository, publication in the book), with the reference to its original publication in this journal.
  3. The authors have the right to post their work on the Internet (e.g. on the institutional store or personal website) prior to and during the review process, conducted by the journal, as this may lead to a productive discussion and a large number of references to this work. (See The Effect of Open Access.)

How to Cite

[1]
Beznin, M.A. and Dimoni, T.M. 2022. Overview of approaches to the study of the power – property model in Soviet Russia of the Stalinist period. Journal of the Belarusian State University. History. 3 (Aug. 2022), 49–60. DOI:https://doi.org/10.33581/2520-6338-2022-3-49-60.