The history of Islam in Indonesian politics of memory

Authors

  • Maksim W. Kyrchanoff Voronezh State University, 1 University Square, Voronezh 394000, Russia

Keywords:

historical politics, politics of memory, Indonesia, Ummah, nationalism, secularism, intellectuals, Masyumi, Islamic State of Indonesia, historical revisionism

Abstract

The article analyses the perception of the history of the Muslim community in the modern Indonesian politics of memory. For the first time in Belarusian historiography, the features of the historical politics or the politics of memory in modern Indonesia are considered. The novelty of the article lies in the integration of Indonesian issues into the contexts of modern interdisciplinary memorial studies. The key subjects of the politics of memory in Indonesia are determined in contexts of the revision of the history of political Islam in the second half of the 20th century. The activity of the media is considered as the main form of the revision of history, criticism of old historical narratives and the formation of a new memorial canon of the history of Indonesian Islam. Attempts to revise the history of Islam are analysed, including new interpretations of Muslim activists, who impact participated in the national movement. The author analyses the contradictions of historical politics in the context of integration of the history of Indonesian political Islam of the 20th century into the secular memorial canon. It is assumed that attempts to construct the history of political Islam in the modern collective Indonesian memory have a compromise character. The author shows how intellectuals assimilate the history of Islam, integrating it into the current memorial canon. It is noted that within the framework of the politics of memory, ideologically and politically controversial points related to the history of radical political Islam, which in the early model of national memory were marginalised and forgotten. Modern manipulations with historical memory are analysed as attempts to achieve a memorial compromise between secular intellectuals and representatives of the Muslim community.

Author Biography

  • Maksim W. Kyrchanoff, Voronezh State University, 1 University Square, Voronezh 394000, Russia

    doctor of science (history); associate professor at the department of regional studies and foreign countries economics, faculty of international relations, and associate professor at the department of history of foreign countries and Oriental studies, faculty of history

References

  1. Scherrer J. [Germany and France: Vergangenheitspolitik]. Pro et contra. 2009;3–4:89–108. Russian.
  2. Todorova M. Bones of contention: the living archive of Vasil Levski and the making of Bulgaria’s national hero. Budapest: Central European University Press; 2009. 600 p.
  3. Miller A. [Russia: power and history]. Pro et contra. 2009;3–4:7–11. Russian.
  4. Chandra S. New findings on the Indonesian killings of 1965–1966. The Journal of Asian Studies. 2017;76(4):1059–1086.
  5. Gilang Desti Parahita, Yulianto VI. The treachery on YouTube: the politics of memory on new media in Indonesia. Archipel. 2020;90:47–73.
  6. Espena D. Remembering 1965: Indonesian cinema and the «Battle of history». Asian Studies: Journal of Critical Perspectives on Asia. 2017;53(1):39–65.
  7. Bubandt N. Ghosts with trauma: global imaginaries and the politics of post-conflict memory. In: Hedman E, editor. Conflict, violence, and displacement in Indonesia. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press; 2018. p. 275–302.
  8. Ikhwan Y, Yulianto VI, Parahita GD. The contestation of social memory in the new media: a case study of the 1965 killings in Indonesia. Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies. 2019;12(1):3–16.
  9. Adam AW. Beberapa catatan tentang historiografi Gerakan 30 September 1965. Archipel. 2018;95:11–30.
  10. Budiawan. Mematahkan pewarisan ingatan wacana anti-komunis dan politik rekonsiliasi Pasca-Soeharto. Jakarta: ELSAM; 2004. 291 p.
  11. Budiawan. When memory challenges history: Public contestation of the Past in Post-Soeharto Indonesia. Southeast Asian Journal of Social Science. 2000;28(2):35–57.
  12. Kyrchanoff MW. «Working out of the Past» in Indonesia: difficulties and complexities of the «remembrance» about the 1965–1966 massacres in the context of competing historical memories and collective representations about past. In: Kyrchanoff MW, editor. Acta Orientalia Voronensia. Voronezh Oriental Studies. Voronezh: Publishing house of Voronezh State University; 2016. p. 86–101. Russian.
  13. Koposov N. [Historical concepts in a world without a future]. In: Garreta G, Dyufo G, Pimenova L, editors. Kak my pishem istoriyu [How we write history]. Мoscow: ROSSPEN; 2013. p. 57–93. Russian.
  14. Barkowski P. [Intellectual manifesto: here and now]. Palitychnaja sfera. 2013;2:94–97. Belarusian.
  15. McPherson J. Revisionist historians. Perspectives on History. 2002;41(6):1.
  16. Smith AD. Nationalism and the historians. International Journal of Comparative Sociology. 1992;33(1–2):58–80.
  17. Krom М. [The use of concepts in research on the history of pre-Petrine Russia]. In: Garreta G, Dyufo G, Pimenova L, editors. Kak my pishem istoriyu [How we write history]. Мoscow: ROSSPEN; 2013. p. 94–125. Russian.
  18. Traba R. [Polish disputes about history in the 21st century]. Pro et contra. 2009;3–4:43–64. Russian.
  19. Kolesnyk I. [Ukrainian historian and government]. Ejdos. 2017;9:9–24. Ukrainian.
  20. Lastowski A. [Studying the communist past in Slovakia]. Palitychnaja sfera. 2016;1:37–55. Belarusian.
  21. Krystev D. Canon and / or agon. In: Vacheva A, Chobanov G, compilers. Kultura i kritika. Chast 3. Krajat na modernostta? [Culture and criticism. Part 3. The end of modernity?]. Varna: LiterNet; 2003:416–449. Bulgarian.
  22. Coakley J. Mobilising Past: nationalist images of history. Nationalism and Ethnic Politics. 2004;10(4):531–560.
  23. Ivanova E. Minalo nesv’rshvashto [The past is not ending]. Sofia: New Bulgarian University; 2011. 231 p. Bulgarian.

Published

2022-08-08

How to Cite

[1]
Kyrchanoff, M.W. 2022. The history of Islam in Indonesian politics of memory. Journal of the Belarusian State University. History. 3 (Aug. 2022), 82–92. DOI:https://doi.org/10.33581/2520-6338-2022-3-82-92.