Criminal procedural conflicts
Keywords:
conflict, criminal procedure, criminal case, subject, court, prosecutor, investigator, defense lawyerAbstract
Criminal procedural conflicts are a type of sectoral legal conflicts. They arise between participants in criminal proceedings who have opposing interests and goals. Their occurrence is associated with the presence of a criminal legal conflict (crime). It is necessary to differentiate between the concepts and phenomena «legal conflict» and «juristic conflict». A legal conflict is a potential conflict. The model for its prevention and resolution is laid down in legislation. A juristic conflict is a legal conflict realised in the actions of subjects. The legislation regulates the resolution of criminal procedural conflicts between professional lawyers (judge, prosecutor, investigator, defense lawyer) in sufficient detail. In resolving any criminal procedural conflicts, the discretion of the law enforcement officer is essential.
References
- Kudryavtsev VN. [Legal conflict]. Gosudarstvo i pravo. 1995;9:9–14. Russian.
- Zakhar’yashcheva IYu. [Legal conflict as a social prerequisite for procedural activity]. Yurist. 2004;4:46–51. Russian.
- Kulakova YuYu. [The essence of the legal conflict]. Istoriya gosudarstva i prava. 2008;14:4–7. Russian.
- Kuz’mina MN. Yuridicheskii konflikt: teoriya i praktika razresheniya [Legal conflict: theory and practice of resolution]. Moscow: Yurlitinform; 2008. 256 p. Russian.
- Tikhomirov YuA, editor. Yuridicheskii konflikt [Legal conflict]. Moscow: Infra-M; 2019. 312 p. Russian.
- Lebedev NYu. Osnovy teorii ugolovno-protsessual’nykh konfliktov [Fundamentals of the theory of criminal-procedural conflicts]. Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk State University of Economics and Management; 2009. 114 p. Russian.
- Tsentr konfliktologicheskikh issledovanii RAN. Yuridicheskaya konfliktologiya. Chast’ 2. Yuridicheskii konflikt: sfery i mekhanizmy [Legal conflictology. Part 2. Legal conflict: spheres and mechanisms]. Moscow: Tsentr konfliktologicheskikh issledovanii RAN; 1994. 172 p. Russian.
- Baev OYa. Konflikty v deyatel’nosti sledovatelya (voprosy teorii) [Conflicts in the activities of the investigator (questions of theory)]. Voronezh: Izdatel’stvo Voronezhskogo universiteta; 1981. 160 p. Russian.
- Lazareva V, Taran A. [Conflicts between professional participants in criminal proceedings: problems of resolution]. Ugolovnoe pravo. 2006;1:91–95. Russian.
- Bibilo VN. Teoriya i istoriya prava, sudoustroystva i ugolovnogo protsessa [Theory and history of law, judicial system and criminal process]. Minsk: Pravo i economika; 2020. 510 p. (Seriya «Nauchnye trudy belorusskikh uchenykh»). Russian.
- Popov DP. The right to defense in criminal proceedings: problems of gaps of legislative regulation. Advokatskaya praktika. 2024;3:31–34. Russian. DOI: 10.18572/1999-4826-2024-3-31-34.
- Frantsiforov YuV, Gorshkova KN. The right of participants in criminal proceedings to appeal at pre-trial stages. Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel’stve. 2024;17(5):94–99. Russian. DOI: 10.33693/2072-3164-2024-17-5-094-099.
- Knyazkov AA. [Legality of restricting the defense in familiarisation with case materials: conclusions from practice]. Ugolovnyi protsess. 2024;9:54–61. Russian.
- Dolgieva M. [Removal of a defense lawyer from participation in trial]. Zakonnost’. 2024;9:45–50. Russian.
