Court decisions on forcing to sign an employment contract: problems and prospects

  • Nataliya N. Nikanava Belarusian State University, 4 Niezaliezhnasci Avenue, Minsk 220030, Belarus

Abstract

In the Soviet period of the development of labour law the idea of the possibility of forcing an employer to conclude an employment contract on the basis of a court decision in the event of an unreasonable refusal to hire a candidate became widespread. Despite the fact that this method of protecting the rights of a person who wishes to be hired is not directly provided for by the Labour Code of the Republic of Belarus, an indication of it was enshrined in part 2, clause 4 of the provision of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Belarus of 29 March 2001 No. 2 «On some issues of application labour law by the courts». The issue of the acceptability of such a method of protecting the rights of an employee as forcing an employer to conclude an employment contract became topical because of changing approaches and trends in the field of labour law, the adoption of the Law of the Republic of Belarus of 24 October 2016 No. 439-З «On enforcement proceedings», planned changes to art. 415 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Belarus and estimated adoption of the Code of Civil Procedure of the Republic of Belarus. The author concludes that in case of an unreasonable refusal to hire the choice of a method of protection is the prerogative of the plaintiff, forcing the employer to conclude an employment contract cannot be considered as the only or main method of protection, the decision on employment contract coercion must contain the necessary terms of such a contract. It is proposed to legislate the possibility of collecting in favour of the employee an amount equal to three times the nominal accrued average salary of employees of the Republic of Belarus for the month preceding the date of the unjustified refusal to hire.

Author Biography

Nataliya N. Nikanava, Belarusian State University, 4 Niezaliezhnasci Avenue, Minsk 220030, Belarus

PhD (law); associate professor at the department of civil procedure and labour law, faculty of law

References

  1. Kolyadko IN. [Labour Code and procedural means of protection]. Promyshlenno-torgovoe pravo. 2003;3:97–100. Russian.
  2. Skobelev VP. [Appealing in court the refusal to conclude an employment contract: procedural problems of choosing the type of proceedings]. In: Tomashevskii KL, editor. Reformirovanie zakonodatel’stva o trude, sotsial’noi zashchite i ekologii na postsovetskom prostranstve [Reforming the legislation on labour, social protection and ecology in the post-Soviet space]. Minsk: Internftional University «MITSO»; 2012. p. 102–108. Russian.
  3. Avdei AG, Agievets SV, Kuryleva OS, Motina EV, Petochenko TM, Yasinskaya-Kazachenko AV. Trudovye spory i ikh uregulirovanie [Labour disputes and their settlement]. Minsk: Publishing Centre of the Belarusian State University; 2015. 244 p. Russian.
  4. Tal’ LS. Trudovoi dogovor: tsivilisticheskoe issledovanie [Employment contract: a civilistic study]. Moscow: Statut; 2006. 539 p. Russian.
  5. Smirnov OV. Osnovnye printsipy sovetskogo trudovogo prava [Basic principles of Soviet labour law]. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura; 1977. 216 p. Russian.
  6. Livshits RZ. [Freedom of labour in the USSR]. In: Chkhikvadze VM, editor. Sotsializm i lichnost’ [Socialism and personality]. Moscow: Institut gosudarstva i prava Akademii nauk; 1979. p. 47–56. Russian.
  7. Babitskii AM. [The principle of freedom of the labour contract in the Soviet labour law]. Pravovedenie. 1989;1:21–29. Russian.
  8. Bugrov LYu. Svoboda truda i svoboda trudovogo dogovora v SSSR (yuridicheskii aspekt) [Freedom of labour and freedom of labour contract in the USSR (legal aspect)]. Krasnoyarsk: Publishing House of Krasnoyarsk University; 1984. 128 p. Russian.
  9. Magnitskaya EV, Pashkov AS. Raspredelenie trudovykh resursov: pravovye voprosy [Allocation of labour resources: legal issues]. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura; 1980. 176 p. Russian.
  10. Krivoi VI. Zaklyuchenie trudovogo dogovora [Conclusion of an employment contract]. Minsk: Belbiznespress; 1997. 64 p. Russian.
  11. Sennikov NM. [Refusal to hire: lessons from judicial practice]. Trudovoe pravo. 2009;4:19–31. Russian.
  12. Sennikov NM. [Refusal to hire: lessons from judicial practice]. Trudovoe pravo. 2009;5:19–31. Russian.
  13. Vostretsova OA. [Legal consequences of refusal to hire]. Trudovoe pravo. 2009;4:13–18. Russian.
  14. Khokhlov EB, editor. Kurs rossiiskogo trudovogo prava. Tom 3. Trudovoi dogovor [The course of Russian labour law. Volume 3. Employment contract]. Saint Petersburg: Yuridicheskii tsentr Press; 2007. 656 p. Russian.
  15. Russkikh TV. Svoboda storon trudovogo dogovora pri ego zaklyuchenii, izmenenii, rastorzhenii i predely ee ogranicheniya [Freedom of the parties to the employment contract in its conclusion, amendment, termination and the limits of its limitation] [dissertation]. Izhevsk: Udmurt State University; 2011. 202 p. Russian.
  16. Tarusina NN, Lushnikov AM, Lushnikova MV. Sotsial’nye dogovory v prave [Social contracts in law]. Moscow: Prospekt; 2017. 480 p. Russian.
  17. Vasilevich GA, Tomashevskii KL, editors. Trudovoe pravo [Labour law]. Minsk: Adukacyja i vyhavanne; 2022. 623 p. Russian.
  18. Volk EA, Kostevich KS, Popok EM, Tomashevskii KL. Ideya svobody v trudovom prave [The idea of freedom in labour law]. Minsk: Amalfeya; 2015. 208 p. Russian.
  19. Kratenko MV. Zloupotreblenie svobodoi dogovora: chastnopravovye i publichno-pravovye aspekty [Abuse of freedom of contract: private law and public law aspects]. Moscow: Walters Kluwer; 2010. 208 p. Russian.
  20. Ivanchina YuV. [Fundamentals of the formation of the function of social solidarity and compromise of the labour law of Russia]. Ezhegodnik trudovogo prava. 2021;11:101–114. Russian.
  21. Ivanov SA, Livshits RZ, Orlovsky YuP. Sovetskoe trudovoe pravo: voprosy teorii [Soviet labour law: questions of theory]. Moscow: Nauka; 1978. 368 p. Russian.
  22. Khokhlov EB, editor. Kurs rossiiskogo trudovogo prava. Tom 1. Obshchaya chast’ [The course of Russian labour law. Volume 1. General part]. Saint Petersburg: Publishing House of Saint Petersburg University; 1996. 373 p. Russian.
  23. Novikova NV. On the labour-law attributes of a contract on targeted training [Internet; cited 2022 October 28]. Available from: http://electronic.ruzh.org/?q=ru/system/files/%D0%9D%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B0%20%D0%9D.%D0%92.pdf. Russian.
  24. Anisimov LN. Trudovoi dogovor: zaklyuchenie, izmenenie i prekrashchenie. Prakticheskie rekomendatsii [Employment contract: conclusion, amendment and termination. Practical recommendations]. Moscow: Yustitsinform; 2005. 198 p. Russian.
  25. Zhernakov VV, editor. Trudove pravo [Labour law]. Kharkiv: Pravo; 2012. 496 p. Ukrainian.
  26. Livshits VZ, Orlovskii YuP, editors. Trudovoe pravo Rossii [Labour law of Russia]. Moscow: INFRA-M; 1998. 473 p. Russian.
  27. Belova TA, Kolyadko IN, editors. Grazhdanskii protsess. Osobennaya chast’ [Civil procedure. Special provisions]. Minsk: Publishing Centre of the Belarusian State University; 2022. 552 p. Russian.
  28. Karapetov AG, editor. Dogovornoe pravo (obshchaya chast’): postateinyi kommentarii k stat’yam 420–453 Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Contract law (general provisions): article-by-article commentary on articles 420–453 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow: M-Logos; 2020. 1425 p. Russian.
Published
2023-09-11
Keywords: unreasonable refusal to hire, protection of the rights of the employee, forcing the employer to conclude an employment contract, enforcement proceedings
Supporting Agencies The author is grateful to PhD (law) E. V. Motina for her help during the research.
How to Cite
Nikanava, N. N. (2023). Court decisions on forcing to sign an employment contract: problems and prospects. Journal of the Belarusian State University. Law, 2, 51-61. Retrieved from https://journals.bsu.by/index.php/law/article/view/5480
Issue
No 2 (2023): Journal of the Belarusian State University. Law
Section
Civil Law and Civil Procedure