The moment of the criminal bankruptcy completing and I. S. Tishkevich doctrine of the unfinished crime value for this moment determining
Abstract
Determining of the moment of completing of criminal bankruptcy is connected with the definition of the boundaries of this crimes, the proper criminal-legal assessment of the deed, as well as the effectiveness and practical applicability of art. 239–241 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Belarus. In the science of criminal law, this problem is debatable. However, it did not receive detailed consideration in the domestic literature with reference to the specifics of the Belarusian legislation. In view of significant contribution of professor I. S. Tishkevich in the development of the doctrine of an unfinished crime, it seems advisable to consider his theoretical views in refraction for this discussion. This is extra topical in eve of the sentennial of the scientist. Consideration of the declared problems allowed coming to conclusions that the real public danger of criminal bankruptcy in modern conditions inconsistent with the legislative reflection of the moment of its completing. The findings can be used to improve legislation and law practice.
References
- Tishkevich IS. Izbrannye trudy [Selectas]. Minsk: Editorial board of the magazine «Industrial and Commercial Law»; 2014. 484 p. Russian.
- Smol’sky A. [Analysis of solvency, the identification of signs of false and intentional bankruptcy in the liquidation of a legal entity]. Bulletin of the Supreme Economic Court of the Republic of Belarus. 2004;17:105. Russian.
- Smol’sky AP. Iskazhenie otchetnosti s tsel’yu izbezhat’ otkrytiya konkursnogo proizvodstva [Distortion of reporting in order to avoid the opening of bankruptcy proceedings] [retrieval system]. ConsultantPlus: Belarus / LLC «YurSpektr». Minsk; 2018. Russian.
- Kudryavtsev VN. [Scientific prerequisites of criminalization]. In: Kudryavtsev VN. Kriminologiya i ugolovnaya politika [Criminology and criminal policy]. Moscow; 1985. Russian.
- Nechaev AD. The research framework of dangerization as the first stage of criminalization: harmfulness and diffusion criteria. Penitentsiarnoe pravo: yuridicheskaya teoriya i pravoprimenitel’naya praktika. 2016;2(8):120–124. Russian.
- Mikhalev IY. Bankrotstvo i ugolovnyi zakon [Bankruptcy and the criminal law] [dissertation abstract]. Vladivostok: [publisher unknown]; 2000. Russian.
- Lemyagov AN. [Objective side of deliberate bankruptcy]. Rossiiskii sledovatel’. 2008;23:24. Russian.
- Gulyi AA. [Questions related to the qualification of criminal bankruptcy on the objective side]. Rossiiskii sledovatel’. 2005;1:17. Russian.
- Kuzminov DA. [Damage as a sign of the composition of crimes associated with bankruptcy]. Nauchnyi vestnik Omskoi akademii MVD Rossii. 2011;2:13–16. Russian.
- About amending certain codes of the Republic of Belarus on issues of liability for violations of the law on economic insolvency (bankruptcy): Law of the Republic of Belarus from 20 July 2007 No. 274-З [retrieval system]. National Register of Legal Acts of the Republic of Belarus. 26 July 2007. No. 175, 2/1371. Russian.
- Khilyuta VV. Prepyatstvovanie vozmeshcheniyu ubytkov kreditoru [Obstruction of compensation of losses to the creditor] [retrieval system]. ConsultantPlus: Belarus / LLC «YurSpektr». Minsk; 2018. Russian.
- Kolb BI. Otvetstvennost’ za kriminal’nye bankrotstva [Responsibility for criminal bankruptcies] [dissertation]. Moscow: [publisher unknown]; 2003. Russian.
- Yani PS. [Problems of classification of bankruptcy]. Zakonnost’. 2014;1:38–42. Russian.
- Yani PS. [The complexity of assigning crimes related to bankruptcy crimes]. Zakonodatel’stvo. 2007;8:77–78. Russian.
- On the practice of application by courts of legislation on evasion of payment of taxes, fees (Article 243 of the Criminal Code): Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Belarus from 26 March 2015 No. 1 [Internet] [cited 2018 August 22]. Available from: http:/pravo.by/document/?guid=12551&p0=S21500001&p1=1. Russian.
